Conundrum Tracing 4-1-2

We're at the bottom of a deep, dark pit. Literally. You see, this conundrum has led us down here, where the only sound is the faint hum of desperation.

According to our trusty Conundrum-Tracing 3000 (a fancy calculator that looks like a toaster), the solution to this particular puzzle is hidden somewhere in the vicinity of... well, not here.

You have three options: