It all started when Andy said he wouldn't eat that whole pizza by himself.
But we all know the real question is, did he really not do it?
Or was it just another one of his classic fibs?
According to sources close to the matter, Andy claims it was just a 'small mistake' when asked about it.
But sources close to the matter also say that Andy 'forgot' he was even eating it.
Want to learn more about the art of not doing things you said you wouldn't do? Try the book series for more.