Where the cookie critics come to mock and scorn.
The year is ending and it's time to dish the dirt on the cookies that made our taste buds weep with joy.
A behemoth of a cookie, it was as big as a manhole cover. Too crunchy, too crumbly, and not enough chip.
CM's Review: 2.5/5. The cookie was a disappointment. It was like eating a mouthful of disappointment.
See our review of the cookie of the year 101
Or our review of the cookie of the year 202
Or our review of the cookie of the year 303, the year we forgot what we were eating