It's a real thing, we swear. We've seen it happen to the best of them. Just ask Dave "The Cactus King" who's currently in a coma with 17 cactus-related injuries.
Next Theory »We've spoken to experts in the field, and they assure us this is a thing. Just ask your neighbor who lost a molar to their pet ferret last week.
Next Theory »We've received reports of a particularly brazen tooth fairy who's been known to pilfer teeth for her infamous "Toothy McToothface" costume.
Next Theory »We can confirm that there's a tooth circus in town, and they're looking for a new star. Maybe your tooth is just looking for a chance to shine?
If none of these theories apply, you can try Theory 5: "The Tooth Fairy Was Just Really Hungry" for more information.