Don't worry, it's not just you. The coffee is actually in a superposition of states until you drink it.
When ordering, specify your desired state of consciousness: Superposition, Many-Worlds, or Entanglement.
Be aware that entanglement may lead to unexpected consequences, such as: Entanglement Nightmares.
For the love of all things caffeinated, do not attempt to measure the coffee. It's like trying to measure the position of a wave function. Just drink it and let go.
Read our philosophy for more information on the quantum nature of our coffee.